Cheesy Instant Pot Polenta

4.60 from 10 votes

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Instant Pot Polenta is a no-fuss method for creating a creamy cheesy side dish. Make this cheesy polenta recipe for dinner tonight!

Close up of Instant Pot Polenta with basil on top


Flavor of Polenta

Polenta is made from stone-ground cornmeal but it’s cooked slowly so that it ends up rich and creamy.

It can be enjoyed as a savory or sweet dish. Polenta tastes like a rich corn porridge, but there’s a natural sweetness from the cornmeal as well.

While it’s widely popular across Mexico, South America and the Caribbean, polentas’ roots are found in Italy, where they also call it Italian grits.

Best Ways to Use It

Italian cooks like to make creamy polenta with heavy cream and lots of cheese whisked in. It makes for a wonderful side dish, or cut into polenta rounds, it’s a delicious appetizer or breakfast treat.

It’s also common to see it in dishes like polenta bolognese, where hearty meat sauces are ladled over the top.

For those who don’t like making polenta from scratch, fully cooked polenta in a tube is available at most larger grocery stores. There are plenty of ways to use it from a tube, in both cold and warm preparations.

I love to make it from scratch, and while I enjoy the traditional cheesy method, often times I make a batch and pour it into a buttered dish to set up in the refrigerator overnight. The next morning, I pan fry it and serve it with a drizzle of maple syrup or honey.

Cheesy Instant Pot Polenta

Because it is cooked slowly, typically one would spend lots of time stirring and keeping an eye on the stove top cooking polenta. The good news is, thanks to the Instant Pot, you can make a version with minimal effort on your part.

There’s no stirring involved, and honestly, the recipe is nearly fail-proof! There are just a couple of important things to keep in mind.

Video: Making Instant Pot polenta

Watch the video in the recipe card at the bottom of this post to see my tips for making the creamiest polenta, whether it’s made in a pressure cooker or on the stovetop!

chicken stock pouring over polenta in Instant Pot

Tips for making creamy polenta

Water to Cornmeal Ratio

The correct ratio for making pressure polenta is 4-to-1. This means you need four cups of cooking liquid for one cup of cornmeal.

Use the Porridge Setting

Many people like to skip the preset options and use the manual setting when they make Instant Pot recipes. In most cases, it works perfectly fine but it doesn’t work well with Instant Pot polenta, oatmeal and slower cooking dishes like pudding.

The problem is, the low setting isn’t hot enough and the manual high setting is too hot for foods like those. Unfortunately, the dish ends up clumpy, with a pasty consistency.

Worse yet, there are times when it just burns completely to the bottom of the pot. Then you have to deal with the hassle of the dreaded Instant Pot burn message.

PRO TIP:
To create perfectly creamy polenta in the Instant Pot, use the porridge setting, following the manufacturer’s instructions for your make and model of pressure cooker.

creamy polenta with whisk in Instant Pot

Perform a NATURAL pressure release.

When the Instant Pot polenta finishes cooking, it’s very important that you allow the pressure in the pot to release naturally.

If you don’t do this, when you open the vent to release the pressure, the contents inside the pot will be forced upwards and may clog the steam release valve.

overhead: bowl of creamy cheesy polenta

For this cheesy polenta recipe, I use fresh herbs and two types of cheese. Fresh parsley and basil add a ton of flavor, but oregano would be fantastic too.

You can certainly leave the cheese out if you want, or use different cheeses. Just be sure that they’re grated finely so that they melt well.

Instant Pot polenta served on white plate with remaining in serving bowl

Still Hungry?

Subscribe to my Newsletter, follow me on Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram and YouTube for all my latest recipes and videos.

Cheesy Instant Pot Polenta + Video

4.60 from 10 votes
You can make cheesy creamy polenta in a pressure cooker! With minimal effort on your part, it's amazingly easy to do. No standing over the pot stirring with Instant Pot polenta!
Servings: 6 servings
Prep: 10 minutes
Cook: 30 minutes
Total: 40 minutes

Ingredients 

Instructions 

  • Add the polenta to the Instant Pot and pour the chicken stock over. Add the salt and whisk to break up and lumps. Cover and cook on Porridge setting – High Pressure, Normal with a total of 20 minutes.
  • When done, allow a Natural Release (See Note 2) Release vent value and open lid. Whisk to stir and add the butter and cream. Whisk to incorporate. Add the cheeses and herbs, whisk again until smooth.
  • Serve with fresh cracked black pepper.

Video

Notes

  1. Feel free to use vegetable stock or water.
  2. Natural Release: per manufacturer’s instruction, this is when the cooker is allowed to cool down naturally until the float valve drops down. This may take 10-15 minutes after cooking is finished. After using the “Porridge” setting do not put steam release in venting position otherwise porridge will splatter through steam release. Use Natural Release.
 

Nutrition

Calories: 389kcal | Carbohydrates: 28g | Protein: 18g | Fat: 22g | Saturated Fat: 13g | Cholesterol: 70mg | Sodium: 1126mg | Potassium: 262mg | Sugar: 3g | Vitamin A: 930IU | Vitamin C: 3.8mg | Calcium: 398mg | Iron: 1.1mg

The information shown is an estimate provided by an online nutrition calculator. It should not be considered a substitute for a professional nutritionist’s advice.

Course: Side Dish
Cuisine: American, Italian
Have You Made This Recipe? Let Me Know on InstagramTag @keviniscooking or tag me #keviniscooking!

Kevin

Whether in the kitchen or on the grill, you’ll find me cooking American favorites with a love for BBQ, Mexican and Tex Mex. I’m passionate about making tasty food because life’s too short to be bland!

Free Bonus
5 Secrets to True Tex Mex
Essential recipes & tips for delicious Tex Mex cooking!

email image

Explore More

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

39 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    I have to come clean, I have two Instant Pots, both six quart and use them almost everyday. I had a tremendously great meal at the Harris Ranch in Coalinga, CA yesterday. It was a lamb shank with an incredible sauce and that was served on a bed of cheesy polenta. I make lamb shanks in the instant Pot and they are great. The polenta will be a wonderful addition, thanks for the recipe!

    1. I just love polenta, the savory the better, too. The idea of a lamb shank has me salivating right now. Thanks Marvin! 😉

  2. 5 stars
    Excellent recipe exactly as written. Fresh rosemary and thyme would be great substitutes for the basil.

  3. Thanks for the recipe. Despite following the grain-to-liquid proportion precisely at 1:4, I too got the “burn message” three times during the warm-up process (just before full pressure was achieved) and, after scraping the bottom of the pot with a wooden spatula and increasing the liquid a bit each time, ended up finishing the polenta in the Instant Pot the old-fashioned way by keeping it on “Saute” with lid off and stirring it pretty constantly. Not the process I was expecting but the result was acceptable. So why was this happening? Some thoughts:

    I was using a medium-grind corn meal from Red Mill, which I have used to make good stove-top polenta in the past, though it is probably a bit less coarse than your (or, for that matter Red Mill’s) “polenta” grind, and the slightly finer grind could account for some of it sticking to the bottom of the pot during heating, which causes the “burn” signal. Also, I noticed that Melissa Clark’s Instant Pot cookbook “Dinner in an Instant” calls for a slightly lower proportion of liquid (1:3.33 rather than 1:4) and shorter cooking time (15 mins. rather than 20) BUT she calls for adding a decent amount of fat (olive oil or butter) to the pot from the start, so this may mitigate the sticking in her case.

    I’ll be curious if others try to make this with medium-grind rather than coarse corn meal, to see if some different proportions, cooking times or fat content eliminate the “burn”!

    1. Peter! Apologies for the late reply. Sorry I missed this one.
      Needless to say I decided to make this one again for testing purposes after reading your inquiry so I will have a cheesy batch for dinner tonight all ready. No burn message, no scorched bottom of pan. I thought I might have written cornmeal in the recipe and had to double check! A lot of people tend to use cornmeal in lieu of polenta, but there is a difference. Here is a great article on Cornmeal, Grits and Polenta – Similarities and Differences in ground corn products. Personally I buy and use Golden Pheasant that I pick up at a local market. I do not add the fat in while cooking as you mentioned Melissa Clark’s recipe, just after it’s cooked.
      On another note, I watched a video from Bon Appetit on making polenta in the Instant Pot and they used the Pressure Cooker button (not the Porridge setting/button) on HIGH for 8 minutes. I tried this as well and found it to be a little uncooked for my liking. It’s all a preference, but still no BURN message for me.

  4. My husband is Italian and I was very excited to see this recipe. Unfortunately when I tried it, I got the dreaded “burn” message. Any idea why?

    1. Not quite sure what you mean by the “I got the dreaded “burn” message.” Lorraine. Could you explain?

      1. Hi
        I don’t see a reply to the “dreaded” burn warning. I have tried this twice and always get this warning, the first time I panicked after 30 min and decompressed and opened and stirred, then started again….Again the “dreaded” burn warning but this time it only lasted about 5 min and then continued to cook. I understand from the researching that when you see that message the pot is cooling down and will try again when it thinks its OK? The second attempt I set it on saute and heated it to boiling which thickened it up a bit and hopefully did not create a mass in the bottom of the pot. I then set it to the porridge setting and continued as instructed. Still I got the “dreaded” burn warning, arrgh which lasted 20 min before I cancelled and reset the porride setting, this time it lasted about another 5 min before it proceeded. What to do, all this fiddling around is defeating the convenience factor. any advice

      2. I did indeed reply to your previous message Penny, although I am not familiar with the “dreaded burn message” you mentioned. I’ve never had that appear on my Instant Pot.
        Are you using the same measurements/amounts as in the recipe? Did you cover and cook on the Porridge setting – High Pressure, Normal with a total of 20 minutes? I make this often and have never had n issue. Is your venting value clean and no obstruction possible causing a misread? I just am not sure and would be frustrated myself!

  5. 3 stars
    I tried this last night but it was very soupy after the full 20 minutes at porridge setting. I set it all up again and cooked another 10 minutes on porridge and it was still soupy. I tried to thicken it by cooking it without the lid on the saute setting, whisking often, but it spat too much so I had to put the lid on it. I finally decided it was thick enough then and called it good, even though it never got to the really thick stage. It did set up when it cooled, but I was serving it hot as a bed for an assortment of toppings and didn’t want it that soupy. I’m not sure what went wrong. Next time I may reduce the liquid or do a much longer cooking time.

    1. Alicia you had me a little concerned I might have a typo in the instructions regarding portions so I made it again (thanks, now I have dinner partially done!) and it came out fine. Not quite sure what happened with your making it. You had the following settings for “Porridge”- High Pressure, Normal with a total of 20 minutes correct? With 1 cup polenta to 4 cups liquid (water or broth)? Please let me know!

    2. 3 stars
      I think I know what the problem might be. I used coarse ground cornmeal and it turned out soupy.
      Kevin, what type and/or brand of cornmeal do you use?

      1. I wish we were neighbors so I could see what’s going on. 🙂 I thought I might have written cornmeal in the recipe and had to double check!
        A lot of people tend to use cornmeal in lieu of polenta, but there is a difference. Here is a great article on Cornmeal, Grits and Polenta – Similarities and Differences in ground corn products. Personally I buy and use Golden Pheasant that I pick up at a local market. Keep me posted Melissa!

  6. I must admit I haven’t used polenta which needs up to an hour to cook for years. Instant one is an amazing thing! Combined with cheese and herbs, it makes a divine weekend meal.

    1. I love it for the fact you can have it creamy and quickly! I could eat a bowl of it now, with lots of cheese on top! 🙂

  7. How many minutes did you cook it on the Porridge setting? On the presets you can select Less, Normal or More which all have different cook times. Also, with the “last used memory” not all pots will go to the factory default times so it’s helpful if you say specifically how many minutes you set it for.

    1. Appreciate that Sue! It is the Porridge Setting button, High Pressure, Normal with a total of 20 minutes. I’ll update the recipe, too. Thanks for the inquiry and assist! 🙂

  8. That polenta looks beautiful, Kevin. I’ve never made a good one. Mine always seem like, I don’t know, some kind of construction material. Although I have to say, I’ve also never had a good one. I rarely see in on a menu, and if I do, it rarely is paired with something I find appealing. Weird. Yours, on the other hand, looks like to want to dive right in with both spoons!

    1. I love the stuff, so comforting and the more cheese the better! I have also added the cooked polenta to my food processor and blitzed it until it was ultra smooth, too. Dig in!

  9. Hey Kevin. This looks and sounds delicious! I’m more of a savory polenta person, but for the very reason you stated I don’t make it very often. I love polenta topped with slow braised short ribs or beef burgundy (or spicy shrimp with bacon). I haven’t looked into an instant pot yet, but plan on doing so. I think I actually used my slow cooker more in hot weather. Which instant pot do your have?